Is there a trauma therapy that goes beyond endlessly talking?
Alternative Approaches to Trauma Healing: Beyond CBT and DBT
Trauma is a complex and pervasive issue that affects millions of people worldwide. While traditional talk therapies like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) have been the mainstay of trauma treatment, they may not work for everyone. These therapies primarily engage the cognitive, rational part of the brain, which can be less effective for addressing the deep emotional and somatic experiences associated with trauma. When talk therapy and medication fail to provide relief, it is essential to explore alternative approaches that target the body-brain connection and the deeper emotional system.
CBT, DBT, and the Limitations of Cognitive-Based Therapies for Trauma
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) have become the dominant treatment modalities for trauma in clinical settings, particularly in hospitals and insurance-funded practices. While these therapies can be effective for some individuals, many trauma patients and experienced private practice clinicians find them lacking in addressing the root causes of trauma.
CBT and DBT primarily focus on the cognitive aspects of trauma, engaging the rational and analytical parts of the brain. They aim to change thought patterns and behaviors associated with trauma symptoms, often using techniques like cognitive restructuring, exposure therapy, and mindfulness. However, trauma is not just a cognitive experience; it is deeply rooted in the emotional and somatic systems of the brain and body.
Many patients who have undergone CBT or DBT for trauma report feeling like these therapies only scratch the surface of their experiences. They may learn coping strategies and ways to manage their symptoms, but the underlying emotional wounds and somatic experiences remain unaddressed. Techniques like snapping a rubber band on the wrist to stop anxious thoughts or challenging negative beliefs may provide temporary relief, but they do not facilitate the deep emotional processing necessary for lasting healing.
Moreover, CBT and DBT leave little room for the patient’s intuition and subjective experience in the healing process. These therapies often follow structured protocols and manuals, with the therapist guiding the patient through predetermined steps and techniques. While this approach may be suitable for research and standardization, it can feel rigid and impersonal for many trauma survivors who need a more individualized and collaborative approach.
The preference for CBT and DBT in clinical settings is largely driven by their ease of research and compatibility with medication-based treatments. These therapies are highly structured and manualized, making them easier to study in controlled settings and measure outcomes. They also align well with the medical model of diagnosis and symptom management, which is favored by insurance companies and corporate healthcare systems.
However, the dominance of CBT and DBT in research does not necessarily reflect their effectiveness in real-world clinical practice, particularly for complex trauma cases. Many experienced trauma therapists in private practice have found that somatic and emotionally-focused therapies, such as EMDR, Somatic Experiencing, and Sensorimotor Psychotherapy, yield better results for their clients. These therapies target the deeper emotional and physiological aspects of trauma, facilitating the release and processing of stuck traumatic experiences.
Patients seeking trauma treatment often intuitively know that they need something more than cognitive restructuring or behavioral modification. They are looking for approaches that can access the deeper layers of their brain and emotional system, where trauma memories and sensations are stored. They want to feel heard, understood, and supported in their subjective experiences, rather than being guided through a predetermined treatment protocol.
As the field of trauma therapy continues to evolve, it is crucial to recognize the limitations of CBT and DBT and the need for alternative approaches that address the complexity of trauma. While these therapies have their place in the treatment landscape, they should not be considered the gold standard or the only option for trauma survivors. By expanding our understanding of trauma and embracing somatic, emotional, and intuitive approaches, we can provide more effective and individualized care for those seeking healing from the depths of their traumatic experiences.
To truly heal trauma, it is necessary to engage the whole person – mind, body, and emotions. Somatic and experiential approaches that target the body-brain connection and the emotional system can be powerful tools for trauma resolution. These therapies recognize that trauma is not just a cognitive event but a full-body experience that requires a holistic approach to healing.
How Therapy Got Here: The Corporate Forces Reshaping Trauma Treatment
The current landscape of trauma therapy, dominated by Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), is the result of complex interplay between corporate interests, insurance companies, and research priorities. These forces have gradually reshaped the field, often prioritizing standardization and cost-effectiveness over individualized, depth-oriented approaches.
In recent decades, there has been a noticeable trend towards shrinking the scale and scope of therapy. This shift has been driven primarily by:
Insurance companies:
Seeking to minimize costs, insurers have increasingly favored short-term, manualized treatments that can be easily quantified and measured.
Corporate healthcare systems:
Hospitals and large healthcare providers have embraced therapies that align with the medical model of diagnosis and symptom management, fitting neatly into existing structures and billing practices.
Research funding:
CBT and DBT, with their structured protocols, are easier to study in controlled settings. This has led to an abundance of research supporting these modalities, creating a self-reinforcing cycle of popularity and further study.
Pharmaceutical industry:
The rise of medication-based treatments has dovetailed well with CBT and DBT, as these therapies are often seen as complementary to pharmacological interventions.
The result has been a gradual shift away from longer-term, insight-oriented and somatic therapies towards brief, symptom-focused interventions. CBT, with its emphasis on changing thought patterns and behaviors, has become the poster child for this new paradigm. Its structured nature makes it ideal for research, insurance reimbursement, and integration into corporate healthcare settings.
However, this shift has come at a cost. Many experienced clinicians in private practice argue that these approaches often fail to address the deeper, more complex aspects of trauma. Patients frequently report feeling that CBT and DBT only scratch the surface of their experiences, leaving underlying emotional wounds and somatic experiences unaddressed.
Moreover, the emphasis on standardized protocols has left little room for the intuition and subjective experience of both patients and therapists. The unique, personal nature of trauma often requires a more flexible, individualized approach that can adapt to the specific needs and experiences of each person.
Brainspotting: A Newer Form of EMDR for Targeted Trauma Processing
Brainspotting is an innovative therapeutic modality that has emerged as a powerful tool for trauma processing. Developed by Dr. David Grand, Brainspotting is a more targeted and efficient version of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR). While EMDR has been widely used for trauma treatment, some individuals may find it less effective or experience challenges with the eye movement component.
Brainspotting addresses these limitations by using a more precise and focused approach. Instead of broad eye movements, Brainspotting involves identifying specific eye positions or “brainspots” that correlate with the emotional and somatic experiences of trauma. By holding the gaze on these brainspots, the therapy allows for deep processing and release of traumatic memories and emotions.
Brainspotting works by bypassing the cognitive defenses and accessing the subcortical brain, where trauma memories are stored. This direct access to the emotional system allows for rapid and effective processing of traumatic experiences. Brainspotting sessions often result in profound emotional shifts and the release of long-held traumatic activation in the body.
Compared to EMDR, Brainspotting may offer several advantages. It is a more targeted and efficient approach, requiring less time and fewer sessions to achieve significant results. Brainspotting also allows for greater flexibility in processing, as it does not rely on a strict protocol and can be adapted to the individual’s unique needs and experiences.
Emotional Transformation Therapy: An Exciting New Development in Trauma Treatment
Emotional Transformation Therapy (ETT) is an emerging modality that holds great promise for trauma healing. Developed by Dr. Steven Vazquez, ETT is a comprehensive approach that integrates elements of neuroscience, quantum physics, and energy psychology to facilitate deep emotional healing.
ETT recognizes that trauma is stored not only in the brain but also in the body’s energy system. By working with the biofield, ETT aims to release traumatic energy patterns and restore balance to the mind-body system. The therapy uses a combination of light, color, eye movements, and bilateral stimulation to access and transform emotional experiences at a deep level.
One of the unique aspects of ETT is its use of light and color. Different colors are associated with specific emotional states and can be used to target and process specific traumatic experiences. For example, the color red may be used to work with anger and rage, while blue may be used for sadness and grief. By shining light of specific colors on the body while processing traumatic memories, ETT facilitates the release and transformation of stuck emotional energy.
ETT also incorporates eye movements, similar to EMDR and Brainspotting, to access and process traumatic memories. However, ETT takes a more flexible and intuitive approach, allowing the therapist to adapt the eye movements to the individual’s unique needs and responses.
The combination of light, color, eye movements, and bilateral stimulation in ETT creates a powerful synergistic effect that can lead to rapid and profound emotional healing. Clients often report significant shifts in their emotional states and a greater sense of peace and resolution after ETT sessions.
ETT is a promising new development in trauma treatment that offers a holistic and integrative approach to healing. By working with the body’s energy system and utilizing the power of light and color, ETT can access and transform traumatic experiences at a deep level, facilitating lasting emotional resolution.
Synergistic Nutrition and Micro-Nutrition for Brain Health and Trauma Recovery
Nutrition plays a crucial role in brain health and trauma recovery. Emerging research suggests that specific nutrients and dietary approaches can support the brain’s resilience and facilitate healing from traumatic experiences. Synergistic nutrition and micro-nutrition are two exciting areas that offer promising avenues for optimizing brain function and promoting trauma recovery.
Synergistic nutrition focuses on the idea that certain nutrients work together in synergistic ways to produce enhanced benefits for brain health. Rather than relying on individual nutrients in isolation, synergistic nutrition emphasizes the importance of nutrient combinations and their interactive effects.
For example, the combination of omega-3 fatty acids, particularly EPA and DHA, with antioxidants like vitamin E and selenium has been shown to have synergistic effects on brain function. These nutrients work together to reduce inflammation, protect against oxidative stress, and support the integrity of neural membranes. Omega-3 fatty acids are crucial for brain development and function, while antioxidants help combat the damaging effects of free radicals and oxidative stress.
Another example of synergistic nutrition is the combination of B vitamins, particularly B6, B9 (folate), and B12, with omega-3 fatty acids. These nutrients work together to support the production of neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine, which are essential for mood regulation and emotional well-being. B vitamins are also involved in the methylation cycle, which is crucial for DNA repair and gene expression, processes that can be impacted by trauma.
Micro-nutrition, on the other hand, focuses on the role of specific micronutrients in brain health and trauma recovery. Micronutrients are essential vitamins and minerals that are required in small amounts but play critical roles in brain function.
For example, magnesium is a crucial micronutrient for brain health. It is involved in numerous biochemical reactions in the body, including the regulation of neurotransmitters like glutamate and GABA. Magnesium deficiency has been linked to increased anxiety, depression, and stress reactivity, all of which are common in trauma survivors. Supplementing with magnesium has been shown to have calming effects on the nervous system and may help reduce symptoms of anxiety and depression.
Zinc is another important micronutrient for brain health and trauma recovery. Zinc plays a role in neurotransmitter synthesis, particularly for serotonin and dopamine. It is also involved in the regulation of the stress response and has been shown to have antidepressant effects. Trauma survivors often have lower levels of zinc, and supplementation may help improve mood and reduce symptoms of depression and anxiety.
Synergistic nutrition and micro-nutrition offer exciting possibilities for supporting brain health and promoting trauma recovery. By optimizing nutrient combinations and ensuring adequate intake of essential micronutrients, individuals can support their brain’s resilience and facilitate the healing process. However, it is important to work with a qualified healthcare practitioner when incorporating nutritional strategies into trauma treatment, as individual needs and sensitivities may vary.
QEEG Brain Mapping and Neurostimulation: Innovative Approaches for Trauma Healing
QEEG (Quantitative Electroencephalography) brain mapping and neurostimulation are cutting-edge approaches that offer new possibilities for trauma healing. These technologies provide insights into brain function and allow for targeted interventions to optimize neural activity and promote emotional regulation.
QEEG brain mapping involves recording the electrical activity of the brain using electrodes placed on the scalp. This non-invasive procedure generates a detailed map of brain wave patterns, allowing for the identification of areas of dysregulation or imbalance. In the context of trauma, QEEG can reveal patterns of hyperarousal, hypoarousal, or other abnormalities in brain function that may contribute to symptoms of PTSD, anxiety, or depression.
By analyzing QEEG data, practitioners can develop targeted treatment plans that address the specific neural imbalances associated with trauma. This may involve the use of neurofeedback, a form of brain training that uses real-time feedback to help individuals learn to regulate their brain activity. Neurofeedback has been shown to be effective in reducing symptoms of PTSD, anxiety, and depression by promoting emotional regulation and reducing hyperarousal.
Neurostimulation is another promising approach for trauma healing. Neurostimulation techniques, such as transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) or transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), involve the use of non-invasive devices to stimulate specific areas of the brain. These techniques can modulate neural activity and promote neuroplasticity, the brain’s ability to rewire and adapt in response to new experiences.
In the context of trauma, neurostimulation can be used to target brain regions involved in emotional regulation, such as the prefrontal cortex or the amygdala. By modulating the activity of these regions, neurostimulation can help reduce symptoms of anxiety, depression, and PTSD. For example, TMS has been shown to be effective in reducing symptoms of PTSD by modulating activity in the prefrontal cortex and reducing hyperarousal.
QEEG brain mapping and neurostimulation offer exciting possibilities for trauma healing by providing targeted interventions that address the underlying neural imbalances associated with trauma. These approaches can be used in conjunction with other therapeutic modalities, such as psychotherapy or somatic therapies, to provide a comprehensive and individualized approach to trauma treatment.
Lifespan Integration and Somatic Experiencing: Body-Based Approaches to Trauma Resolution
Lifespan Integration (LI) and Somatic Experiencing (SE) are two body-based approaches that offer powerful tools for trauma resolution. These therapies recognize the importance of the body in trauma healing and provide techniques for processing traumatic experiences at a somatic level.
Lifespan Integration is a gentle and non-invasive therapy that aims to heal past traumas by creating a coherent narrative of one’s life experiences. LI works by guiding individuals through a timeline of their life, from birth to the present, while focusing on significant events and experiences. By revisiting these experiences in a safe and supportive context, LI helps individuals integrate and make sense of their past, reducing the emotional charge associated with traumatic memories.
One of the unique aspects of LI is its use of a “timeline” to organize and process life experiences. The therapist guides the individual through their timeline, stopping at significant events and using specific techniques to help them process and integrate these experiences. This may involve visualization, body awareness, or other techniques that promote a sense of safety and grounding.
LI is particularly effective for individuals who have experienced complex or developmental trauma, such as childhood abuse or neglect. By creating a coherent narrative of one’s life experiences, LI helps individuals develop a sense of continuity and meaning, reducing feelings of fragmentation and disconnection often associated with trauma.
Somatic Experiencing, developed by Dr. Peter Levine, is another body-based approach to trauma healing. SE focuses on the physiological responses to trauma and aims to release the energy and tension held in the body as a result of traumatic experiences.
SE recognizes that trauma is not just a psychological event but also a physiological one. When faced with a life-threatening situation, the body’s natural survival responses of fight, flight, or freeze are activated. However, if these responses are not fully discharged, the energy and tension can become trapped in the body, leading to symptoms of PTSD, anxiety, and other trauma-related disorders.
Somatic Experiencing provides techniques for gently and gradually releasing this trapped energy and tension from the body. The therapist guides the individual through a process of “titration,” which involves slowly and safely exploring the physical sensations and impulses associated with the traumatic experience. By bringing awareness to these sensations and allowing them to be experienced and released in a controlled and supportive environment, SE helps individuals discharge the traumatic energy and restore a sense of safety and regulation in the body.
SE also emphasizes the importance of “resourcing,” which involves helping individuals develop internal and external resources for coping with stress and trauma. This may involve techniques such as grounding, centering, or visualization, which promote a sense of safety and stability.
Lifespan Integration and Somatic Experiencing are powerful body-based approaches to trauma healing that recognize the importance of the somatic experience in trauma resolution. By working with the body and the nervous system, these therapies help individuals release trapped traumatic energy, develop a coherent narrative of their life experiences, and restore a sense of safety and regulation. These approaches can be particularly effective for individuals who have experienced complex or developmental trauma and may be used in conjunction with other therapeutic modalities for a comprehensive approach to healing.
Post-Jungian Modalities: Parts-Based Approaches to Trauma Healing
Post-Jungian modalities, such as Internal Family Systems (IFS) and Voice Dialogue, offer unique and effective approaches to trauma healing. These parts-based therapies recognize that the psyche is composed of multiple sub-personalities or “parts” that have their own unique qualities, roles, and needs. By working with these parts in a compassionate and non-judgmental way, individuals can access and heal the wounded aspects of themselves that carry the burden of traumatic experiences.
Internal Family Systems (IFS), developed by Dr. Richard Schwartz, is a parts-based therapy that views the psyche as an internal family system. IFS recognizes that each individual has multiple sub-personalities or “parts” that have developed as a result of life experiences, including traumatic events. These parts may have taken on specific roles or functions to help the individual cope with stress or trauma, but over time, they can become rigid or extreme in their behaviors.
IFS provides a framework for understanding and working with these parts in a compassionate and non-pathologizing way. The therapist helps the individual develop a relationship with their parts, getting to know their unique qualities, roles, and needs. Through a process of “unblending” from these parts and developing “Self-leadership,” individuals can access their innate wisdom and compassion, and facilitate the healing and integration of wounded parts.
In the context of trauma healing, IFS can be particularly effective in working with parts that carry the burden of traumatic experiences. These parts may hold intense emotions, beliefs, or somatic sensations related to the trauma, and may have taken on protective roles to help the individual survive. By developing a relationship with these parts and understanding their underlying needs and fears, individuals can begin to unburden them and facilitate their healing and integration.
Voice Dialogue, developed by Drs. Hal and Sidra Stone, is another parts-based approach that can be effective in trauma healing. Voice Dialogue recognizes that each individual has multiple selves or “voices” that have their own unique perspectives, feelings, and needs. By engaging in dialogue with these voices, individuals can gain a deeper understanding of their inner world and facilitate the integration of disparate aspects of themselves.
In Voice Dialogue, the therapist helps the individual identify and engage with different voices or selves, such as the “inner critic,” the “wounded child,” or the “protector.” By giving each voice a chance to speak and be heard, individuals can develop a more compassionate and accepting relationship with these aspects of themselves. This can be particularly helpful in working with voices that carry the burden of traumatic experiences, as it allows for the expression and validation of their unique perspectives and needs.
Myofascial Release and Rolfing: Bodywork Approaches for Trauma Resolution
Myofascial release and Rolfing are two powerful bodywork modalities that can play a significant role in trauma healing by addressing the physical manifestations of trauma stored in the body’s tissues.
Myofascial Release
Myofascial release is a hands-on technique that focuses on releasing tension and restrictions in the fascia, the connective tissue that surrounds and supports muscles, bones, and organs throughout the body. Trauma can cause the fascia to become tight, restricted, or adhered, leading to physical pain, limited mobility, and emotional distress.
In the context of trauma healing, myofascial release can:
- Release physical tension: By gently manipulating the fascia, practitioners can help release areas of tension and restriction that may be holding traumatic energy.
- Improve body awareness: The slow, gentle nature of myofascial release encourages clients to tune into their body sensations, promoting greater body awareness and connection.
- Facilitate emotional release: As physical restrictions are released, emotional content associated with the trauma may surface, allowing for processing and integration.
- Support nervous system regulation: The gentle touch and slow pace of myofascial release can help calm the nervous system, promoting a sense of safety and relaxation.
Rolfing Structural Integration
Rolfing, developed by Dr. Ida Rolf, is a form of bodywork that aims to reorganize the body’s connective tissue to promote better alignment, balance, and movement. While not specifically designed as a trauma therapy, Rolfing can be highly effective in addressing the physical imprints of trauma on the body.
Rolfing can contribute to trauma healing in several ways:
- Releasing chronic tension patterns: Rolfing works to release long-held patterns of tension in the body, which may be related to traumatic experiences.
- Improving posture and alignment: By enhancing overall body alignment, Rolfing can help individuals feel more grounded and present in their bodies.
- Enhancing body awareness: The deep tissue work in Rolfing promotes greater proprioception and body awareness, which can be crucial for trauma survivors who may feel disconnected from their bodies.
- Facilitating emotional processing: As physical restrictions are addressed, emotional content related to trauma may surface, providing opportunities for processing and integration.
- Supporting nervous system regulation: The systematic approach of Rolfing, typically delivered in a series of sessions, can help regulate the nervous system over time.
Both myofascial release and Rolfing can be valuable adjuncts to other trauma therapies, offering a body-based approach to complement cognitive and emotional work. These modalities recognize that trauma is not just stored in the mind but also in the body’s tissues, and by addressing these physical imprints, they can facilitate a more comprehensive healing process.
It’s important to note that when using these bodywork approaches for trauma healing, practitioners should be trauma-informed and work in close collaboration with mental health professionals. The process of releasing physical tension can sometimes trigger emotional responses or traumatic memories, so it’s crucial to ensure that clients have adequate support and resources for processing any emerging material.
Speculative Bibliography:
- American Psychological Association. (2017). Clinical Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) in Adults. Washington, DC: APA.
- Grand, D. (2013). Brainspotting: The Revolutionary New Therapy for Rapid and Effective Change. Sounds True.
- Vazquez, S. R. (2005). Emotional Transformation Therapy: An Interactive Ecological Psychotherapy. Rowman & Littlefield.
- Bourre, J. M. (2006). Effects of nutrients (in food) on the structure and function of the nervous system: update on dietary requirements for brain. Part 1: micronutrients. Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging, 10(5), 377-385.
- Thatcher, R. W. (2010). Handbook of Quantitative Electroencephalography and EEG Biofeedback. ANI Publishing.
- Pace, P. (2003). Lifespan Integration: Connecting Ego States through Time. Lifespan Integration, LLC.
- Levine, P. A. (1997). Waking the Tiger: Healing Trauma. North Atlantic Books.
- Schwartz, R. C. (1995). Internal Family Systems Therapy. Guilford Press.
- Stone, H., & Stone, S. (1989). Embracing Our Selves: The Voice Dialogue Manual. New World Library.
Main Points and Key Ideas:
- Limitations of traditional cognitive-based therapies (CBT and DBT) for trauma treatment
- Focus primarily on cognitive aspects
- May not address deeper emotional and somatic experiences
- Can feel impersonal and rigid for some patients
- Influence of corporate and insurance interests on trauma therapy approaches
- Preference for short-term, manualized treatments
- Emphasis on cost-effectiveness and standardization
- Alignment with medical model and pharmacological interventions
- Alternative approaches to trauma healing: a. Brainspotting
- More targeted version of EMDR
- Uses specific eye positions to access and process trauma
b. Emotional Transformation Therapy (ETT)
- Integrates neuroscience, quantum physics, and energy psychology
- Uses light, color, and eye movements for emotional healing
c. Nutritional approaches
- Synergistic nutrition and micro-nutrition for brain health
- Focus on nutrient combinations and specific micronutrients
d. QEEG brain mapping and neurostimulation
- Provides insights into brain function
- Allows for targeted interventions to optimize neural activity
e. Lifespan Integration and Somatic Experiencing
- Body-based approaches to trauma resolution
- Focus on creating coherent life narratives and releasing trapped energy
f. Post-Jungian modalities (Internal Family Systems and Voice Dialogue)
- Parts-based approaches to trauma healing
- Recognize multiple sub-personalities or “parts” within the psyche
- Importance of holistic, individualized approaches to trauma treatment
- Addressing cognitive, emotional, and somatic aspects of trauma
- Recognizing the unique needs and experiences of each individual
- Emerging focus on body-brain connection in trauma healing
- Recognition of trauma as a physiological experience
- Importance of somatic interventions in trauma resolution
- Potential benefits of integrating multiple modalities for comprehensive trauma treatment
Read More Depth Psychology Articles:
Taproot Therapy Collective Podcast
Types of Therapy
0 Comments