Steven Mithen: The Archaeologist of Cognitive Fluidity
While Carl Jung explored the psyche through dreams and myths, Steven Mithen (b. 1960) explores it through flint axes and fossil records. A British archaeologist and anthropologist, Mithen has bridged the gap between evolutionary science and depth psychology. His work provides the “hard science” footing for what Jungians call the Collective Unconscious.
Mithen’s revolutionary contribution is the concept of Cognitive Fluidity. He argues that early human minds were “modular”—like a Swiss Army knife with separate tools for nature, social interaction, and technology that could not talk to each other. The birth of the modern mind occurred when the walls between these modules broke down, allowing metaphors, art, and religion to emerge. This is the archaeological equivalent of the Individuation process: the integration of separated parts into a fluid whole.
The Prehistory of the Mind: A Modular Architecture
In his seminal work The Prehistory of the Mind (1996), Mithen challenges the idea that intelligence is a single, general capacity. Instead, he proposes a three-phase evolution of the human psyche:
Phase 1: General Intelligence (The Early Hominids)
Around 2 million years ago (Australopithecines), ancestors possessed a basic, generalized learning ability similar to chimpanzees. They could learn, but their knowledge was slow and non-transferable.
Phase 2: Specialized Modules (Homo Erectus / Neanderthals)
Between 1.8 million and 100,000 years ago, the mind developed specialized “chapels” or modules:
- Social Intelligence: Managing complex group dynamics (gossip, hierarchy).
- Natural History Intelligence: Understanding animal behavior and terrain.
- Technical Intelligence: Making tools (hand axes).
Crucially, these minds lacked fluidity. A Neanderthal could make a perfect hand axe (technical) and hunt a bear (nature), but they never thought to make a bone flute (combining nature + technical) or a totem animal (combining social + nature). Their creativity was siloed.
Phase 3: The Big Bang of Consciousness (Homo Sapiens)
Around 60,000 years ago, the walls between the chapels collapsed. Intelligence became fluid. Humans began to think metaphorically.
The Result: Anthropomorphism (seeing social agency in nature), Totemism (seeing nature in the social group), and Art (imposing mental images onto physical objects). This Cognitive Fluidity is the biological basis for the symbol-making function of the psyche.
The Singing Neanderthal: Music as Protolanguage
In The Singing Neanderthals (2005), Mithen addresses a mystery: Why do humans have such a deep, instinctual connection to music? He proposes that before humans spoke in words, they communicated in “Hmmmmm”—Holistic, multi-modal, manipulative, musical, mimetic utterances.
This “musical” language was the primary way early humans bonded, expressed emotion, and coordinated hunting.
Psychological Implication: Music is not a byproduct of language; it is older than language. This explains why music bypasses the rational ego and strikes directly at the emotional core (the subcortical brain). For trauma therapy, this validates the use of non-verbal, somatic, and rhythmic interventions to heal wounds that predate the capacity for speech.
The Origins of Religion: Hyperactive Agency Detection
Mithen provides a cognitive explanation for the universal presence of archetypes and gods. He argues that once cognitive fluidity was achieved, the “Social Intelligence” module began to bleed into the “Natural History” module.
Humans began to attribute agency (intent, desire, personality) to inanimate objects. The wind wasn’t just air; it was an angry spirit. The tree wasn’t just wood; it was a listening ancestor. This “Hyperactive Agency Detection Device” (HADD) was evolutionary advantageous (better to mistake a shadow for a lion than a lion for a shadow), but it also populated the world with gods, spirits, and myths.
From a depth psychology perspective, this confirms that the “God-image” is a structural inevitability of the human mind, not a cultural invention.
Legacy: Integrating Science and Soul
Steven Mithen’s work offers a bridge between the “hard” sciences of archaeology and the “soft” sciences of psychology. He demonstrates that the things we value most—metaphor, art, religion, and storytelling—are not luxuries. They are the evolutionary adaptations that allowed us to survive.
For the modern therapist, Mithen’s framework suggests that fragmentation (the lack of fluidity) is a regression to an earlier, pre-human state of mind. Healing is the work of re-establishing fluidity—allowing the technical, emotional, and social parts of the brain to speak to one another once again.
Further Reading & Resources
- Thames & Hudson: The Prehistory of the Mind.
- Harvard University Press: The Singing Neanderthals.
- University of Reading: Academic Profile of Steven Mithen.
0 Comments