The Archetypal Psychology of James Hillman: Re-Visioning the Foundations of Mind and Culture

by | Jul 8, 2024 | 0 comments

James Hillman (1926–2011) founded archetypal psychology, a post-Jungian school that treats the psyche as a field of images rather than a machine to be repaired. Where Jung organized the psyche around a unifying Self, Hillman argued for many figures and many gods, and for a therapy that looks closely at a symptom before it tries to get rid of it.

That last idea is the one worth keeping, and it is the argument of this piece. Hillman’s lasting contribution is a clinical stance more than a system: before you remove a symptom, find out what it is picturing. That stance corrects the medical and developmental habits of modern therapy. It goes wrong when it becomes a reason to skip developmental and safety work. Development is the gap that one of his sharpest critics, the Australian Jungian scholar David Tacey, says unmade Hillman’s model.22

I have a complicated relationship with Hillman’s work. On our podcast I have interviewed his son, Laurence Hillman, who works with archetypes through astrology and leadership coaching, and David Tacey, who knew Hillman personally. Laurence’s archetypal astrology sits in the same family as Richard Tarnas’s archetypal reading of cultural history. Hillman’s insistence that psychology belongs in the street and the world, and not only in the consulting room, is the other half of his legacy, and this piece comes back to it.

James Hillman in a filmed interview, seated in a light shirt and green tie with potted plants behind him

Who James Hillman was

Hillman was born on April 12, 1926, at the Breakers, an Atlantic City hotel his family had founded.1 He spent two years in the US Navy Hospital Corps during the Second World War, then studied at the Sorbonne in Paris and at Trinity College Dublin.2 In 1959 he completed a doctorate at the University of Zurich and his training as a Jungian analyst, and that same year he became Director of Studies at the C.G. Jung Institute in Zurich, a post he held for ten years.2

In 1970 he became editor of the journal Spring.2 His Terry Lectures at Yale in 1971–72 became Re-Visioning Psychology (1975).3,4 His obituary and the archive that holds his papers both record that it was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize.1,2 He returned to the United States as Dean of Graduate Studies at the University of Dallas, and in November 1980 he and five former University of Dallas colleagues, Donald Cowan, Louise Cowan, Robert Sardello, Joanne Stroud and Gail Thomas, founded the Dallas Institute of Humanities and Culture.2,5

He taught at Yale, the University of Chicago and Syracuse University, and published more than nineteen books plus volumes of essays.2 The men’s movement made him a public figure: he co-edited the poetry anthology The Rag and Bone Shop of the Heart (1992) with Robert Bly and Michael Meade, and the New York Times headlined his obituary “James Hillman, Therapist in Men’s Movement, Dies at 85.”6,7 In 2001 he received the Medal of the Presidency of the Italian Republic. He died of metastatic bone cancer at his home in Thompson, Connecticut, on October 27, 2011.1

Year Major book
1964 Suicide and the Soul
1972 The Myth of Analysis: Three Essays in Archetypal Psychology (Northwestern University Press)
1975 Re-Visioning Psychology (Harper & Row)
1979 The Dream and the Underworld
1983 Archetypal Psychology: A Brief Account; Healing Fiction
1992 We’ve Had a Hundred Years of Psychotherapy, and the World’s Getting Worse, with Michael Ventura
1996 The Soul’s Code: In Search of Character and Calling
2004 A Terrible Love of War
2013, posthumous Lament of the Dead, with Sonu Shamdasani, on Jung’s Red Book

What archetypal psychology is

Archetypal psychology starts from imagination. Hillman’s working assumption was that the psyche shows itself first as images: the figures in a dream, a mood that seems to have a face, the fantasy that quietly runs a career or a marriage. His obituary in the American Psychologist puts it plainly: he moved away from a dependence on the personal ego toward a “variegated identity,” a crowd of mythical images gathered under the word soul.1 He set out the program in short form in Archetypal Psychology: A Brief Account (1983).8

The word soul came with a poet attached. Hillman took “soul-making” from John Keats.2 In a long letter to his brother and sister-in-law in the spring of 1819, Keats rejected the idea of the world as a “vale of tears” and wrote: “Call the world if you please ‘The vale of Soul-making.'” A little further on he asked, “Do you not see how necessary a World of Pains and troubles is to school an Intelligence and make it a soul?”9 That sentence is close to the whole of Hillman’s clinical attitude. Suffering is not proof that something has malfunctioned. It is part of how a person becomes particular.

Hillman’s quarrel with Jung was about the center. Jung’s late psychology, and followers such as Edward Edinger in Ego and Archetype (1972), gave the Self a governing role, an inner unity toward which a life develops. Hillman read that as a monotheistic habit and proposed a polytheistic psychology instead: many centers, many gods, none of them entitled to silence the rest. His essay “Psychology: Monotheistic or Polytheistic?” was printed as the appendix to the 1981 edition of David L. Miller’s The New Polytheism.10

The gods in this picture are not beliefs. They are styles of experience. A line often quoted to make the point, including on an earlier version of this page, is credited to Hillman, but it is Jung’s. In his commentary on The Secret of the Golden Flower, published in English in 1931, Jung wrote: “The gods have become diseases; not Zeus, but the solar plexus, now rules Olympus and causes the oddities of the professional office hour.”11 The wording that circulates online comes from a later translation. Hillman’s project can be read as a long answer to that sentence: if the gods now arrive as symptoms, then a symptom deserves the attention once paid to a god.

Hillman placed himself in a line running from Heraclitus, Plato and Plotinus through Ficino, Vico and Coleridge to Freud and Jung, with Keats, Bachelard and Henry Corbin close at hand.2 By the 1980s the approach was distinct enough that Andrew Samuels gave it its own chapter in his survey Jung and the Post-Jungians (1985), and The Cambridge Companion to Jung later treated “the archetypal school” as one of the main branches of the field.12,13 Thomas Moore, whose Care of the Soul (1992) later carried these ideas to a mass audience, edited the Hillman reader A Blue Fire (1989); see our profile of Thomas Moore and his vision of the soul.14 And Ginette Paris’s attempt to square depth psychology with neuroscience, in Wisdom of the Psyche (2007), carries the archetypal style into a newer debate.

Pathologizing: why Hillman would not hurry to cure

Hillman’s most provocative term is pathologizing: the psyche’s habit of falling ill, producing symptoms, fixations, depressions and morbid fantasies. Stern’s obituary lists it, alongside dreams and chaos, among the places where Hillman thought soul is most fully experienced.1 The point is not that suffering is good. It is that a symptom is also an image with its own shape, and a therapy that only asks how to make it stop has decided in advance that it has nothing to say.

The publisher’s description of Jason Butler’s book-length account of Hillman’s clinical legacy summarizes the shift this way: archetypal psychology moved the focus of therapy “away from cure of the symptom toward vivification and expression of the mythopoetic imagination,” and beyond “mere ego-adaptation and coping.”15 The Myth of Analysis (1972), subtitled Three Essays in Archetypal Psychology, was an early statement of the approach. The Dream and the Underworld (1979), which began as a shorter piece in the 1973 Eranos yearbook, took it furthest.16 In it Hillman tied dreams to death and the mythic underworld rather than to the ego’s daytime agenda, so a dream is something to visit and look around in before it is something to decode into advice.

This is a real corrective. Much of modern therapy treats a symptom as an error message to be reduced and measured, and for many problems that works; people deserve relief. But a panic that returns at the same threshold, or a depression that settles in after a person has abandoned something they loved, can carry information that a symptom checklist will not capture.

The Soul’s Code and the acorn theory

Hillman’s widest audience came with The Soul’s Code: In Search of Character and Calling (Random House, 1996). The archive that holds his papers says it stayed on the New York Times best-seller list for nearly a year.2 Its central idea, which Hillman called the acorn theory, holds that each life is formed by a particular image that calls it toward a destiny, the way the oak is held in the acorn. The publisher’s description notes that “Plato and the Greeks called it ‘daimon,’ the Romans ‘genius,’ the Christians ‘guardian angel.'”17 We trace that word through the history of therapy in what the daimon is and how it became the authentic self.

The Greek source is the Myth of Er at the end of Plato’s Republic. Before birth, the souls are told, “Your genius will not be allotted to you, but you will choose your genius.” Each chosen genius is then sent with its soul “to be the guardian of their lives and the fulfiller of the choice,” and the souls drink from the river of Unmindfulness, so that each one “forgot all things.”18 Read alongside Hillman, the myth explains in its own terms why a calling has to be rediscovered rather than simply remembered.

In practice the book is an argument against reading a person only as the product of genes and upbringing. It treats childhood oddities and “symptoms” as clues to what the daimon wants, and it draws its examples from extraordinary lives, from Yehudi Menuhin to Jeffrey Dahmer.17 As a way of reading a biography it can be freeing: someone who has only heard their history as a list of damages may find it steadying to ask what in them has been insisting on itself all along. As a theory, though, it is a myth, not a hypothesis anyone has tested, and it becomes harmful if it is used to explain away a child’s learning disability, to tell someone their abuse was fated, or to excuse an adult’s cruelty as calling.

Soul in the world: therapy, cities and the anima mundi

Hillman’s later work turned outward. The title of We’ve Had a Hundred Years of Psychotherapy, and the World’s Getting Worse (1992), written with Michael Ventura, states the argument: a century of looking inward had not made the outer world better, and therapy had taught people to treat as private what was partly public.19 In the essays gathered in The Thought of the Heart and the Soul of the World (1992) he revived the old Platonic idea of the anima mundi, the soul of the world, and he wrote one of the two forewords to the 1995 anthology Ecopsychology.20,21 His writings on cities were collected in City & Soul (2006), and in A Terrible Love of War (2004) he took on the attraction of war itself.

A historical-materialist critic would recognize the move. If a whole culture is anxious, sleepless and depressed, the cause lies partly in the work, the cities and the economy people live in, not only inside each person. Hillman made the case aesthetically rather than economically: ugly, hurried surroundings make an ugly, hurried inner life. Both readings refuse to let the individual carry the whole weight of a collective problem.

Where Hillman goes wrong: development, the puer and the evidence

One of the strongest critiques of Hillman comes from inside the Jungian world. In a two-part essay in the Journal of Analytical Psychology, David Tacey argued that Hillman’s work is “not so much post-Jungian as pre-Jungian,” and that his model was “unmade” by its missing developmental element. “Development is an archetypal and bio-psychological necessity,” Tacey wrote, “and if rejected it can ruin any system that refuses to take it seriously.”22 His second part reads Hillman’s own character through the puer aeternus, the eternal youth who prefers to live in a dream-state that resists growing up.22,23 We take up the same tension in our essay on Hillman’s war with the ego.

Clinically, Tacey’s point lands. People in therapy usually need to build things: a steadier sense of self, the ability to tolerate feeling, skills for relationships, a nervous system that can settle. Jungians who keep a developmental frame, such as James Hollis in his work on the psychodynamics of the self and his midlife book The Middle Passage (1993), have an easier time holding images and growth together.24

The evidence needs saying plainly. Psychodynamic therapy as a broad family has respectable support; a widely cited review in the American Psychologist found effect sizes comparable to treatments marketed as evidence-based, with gains that tended to hold after therapy ended.25 Jungian therapy specifically has a smaller base of naturalistic outcome studies, mostly from Germany and Switzerland, and its own researchers say there is “a strong need for further research, especially with randomized controlled trial designs.”26,27 Archetypal psychotherapy as Hillman practiced it has, as far as I can find, no controlled outcome research at all. Butler’s book illustrates its method with dreams, fantasy images and clinical vignettes rather than trial data.15 That does not make the ideas worthless. It means they are a way of seeing, and should be offered as one.

What this looks like in therapy

Used well, Hillman’s stance slows interpretation down. When a dream brings a black dog, the first move is not to announce that the dog means depression, but to stay with the dog: how it moves, where it stands, what it does when the dreamer turns toward it. The image often knows more than the label. It also changes how a mood is heard. Asking what a heaviness looks like, where it sits or how old it seems can yield more than asking only how bad it is on a scale of one to ten.

It also makes room for more than one voice. A person who says “part of me wants to leave and part of me cannot” is already speaking polytheistically, and taking each part seriously without forcing a quick verdict is common ground between Hillman, Jungian active imagination and modern parts-based therapy. And it keeps the outer world in view: exhaustion from work that has no meaning is not only a private disorder.

Used badly, the same stance becomes an excuse. Severe depression, thoughts of suicide, mania, psychosis or an eating disorder call for safety planning and proper care first, often including a medical evaluation and a conversation with a prescriber; our page on depression treatment in Hoover describes how we approach that. If you are in crisis in the United States, call or text 988. Trauma survivors should never be told that what happened to them was necessary for their soul. The respectful version of Hillman’s idea is simpler: what is happening to you is worth looking at closely, and you can be helped while it is looked at.

If you want to work with dreams, images and the larger story of your life alongside practical help with symptoms, our Jungian depth therapy in Hoover page explains how sessions work and who they tend to suit.

References

  1. Stern, E. M. (2012). James Hillman (1926–2011). American Psychologist, 67(6), 496. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0028998
  2. OPUS Archives and Research Center. (n.d.). The James Hillman collection. https://www.opusarchives.org/james-hillman-collection/
  3. The Dwight H. Terry Lectureship. (n.d.). Previous lectureships. Yale University. https://terrylecture.yale.edu/previous-lectureships
  4. Hillman, J. (1975). Re-visioning psychology. Harper & Row.
  5. Dallas Institute of Humanities and Culture. (n.d.). About. https://dallasinstitute.org/about/
  6. Bly, R., Hillman, J., & Meade, M. (Eds.). (1992). The rag and bone shop of the heart: Poems for men. HarperCollins.
  7. Carey, B. (2011, October 28). James Hillman, therapist in men’s movement, dies at 85. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/28/health/james-hillman-therapist-in-mens-movement-dies-at-85.html
  8. Hillman, J. (1983). Archetypal psychology: A brief account. Spring Publications.
  9. Keats, J. (1925). Letters of John Keats to his family and friends (S. Colvin, Ed.). Macmillan. (Original work published 1891). Letter to George and Georgiana Keats, February 14 to May 3, 1819. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/35698
  10. Miller, D. L. (1981). The new polytheism: Rebirth of the gods and goddesses (with prefatory letters by H. Corbin and an appendix by J. Hillman). Spring Publications.
  11. Wilhelm, R., & Jung, C. G. (1931). The secret of the golden flower: A Chinese book of life (C. F. Baynes, Trans.). Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner. https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.175702
  12. Samuels, A. (1985). Jung and the post-Jungians. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
  13. Adams, M. V. (2008). The archetypal school. In P. Young-Eisendrath & T. Dawson (Eds.), The Cambridge companion to Jung (2nd ed., pp. 107–124). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CCOL9780521865999.007
  14. Hillman, J. (1989). A blue fire: Selected writings (T. Moore, Ed.). Harper & Row.
  15. Butler, J. A. (2014). Archetypal psychotherapy: The clinical legacy of James Hillman. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315856803
  16. Hillman, J. (1979). The dream and the underworld. Harper & Row.
  17. Hillman, J. (1996). The soul’s code: In search of character and calling. Random House.
  18. Plato. (1998). The republic (B. Jowett, Trans.). Project Gutenberg. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/1497
  19. Hillman, J., & Ventura, M. (1992). We’ve had a hundred years of psychotherapy, and the world’s getting worse. HarperSanFrancisco.
  20. Hillman, J. (1992). The thought of the heart and the soul of the world. Spring Publications.
  21. Roszak, T., Gomes, M. E., & Kanner, A. D. (Eds.). (1995). Ecopsychology: Restoring the earth, healing the mind (forewords by L. R. Brown and J. Hillman). Sierra Club Books.
  22. Tacey, D. (2014). James Hillman: The unmaking of a psychologist. Part one: His legacy. Journal of Analytical Psychology, 59(4), 467–485. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-5922.12094
  23. Tacey, D. (2014). James Hillman: The unmaking of a psychologist. Part two: The problem of the puer. Journal of Analytical Psychology, 59(4), 486–502. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-5922.12095
  24. Hollis, J. (1993). The middle passage: From misery to meaning in midlife. Inner City Books.
  25. Shedler, J. (2010). The efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy. American Psychologist, 65(2), 98–109. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0018378
  26. Roesler, C. (2013). Evidence for the effectiveness of Jungian psychotherapy: A review of empirical studies. Behavioral Sciences, 3(4), 562–575. https://doi.org/10.3390/bs3040562
  27. Roesler, C., & Reefschläger, G. I. (2022). Jungian psychotherapy, spirituality, and synchronicity: Theory, applications, and evidence base. Psychotherapy, 59(3), 339–350. https://doi.org/10.1037/pst0000402

Explore the Other Articles by Categories on Our Blog 

What are the most common images in dreams?

What are the most common images in dreams?

Dreams keep their place in therapy because they are the purest projective material available. Nobody wrote them, nobody edited them, and the person who produced them was not trying to make an impression. In a way, dreams are our own personal mythology. Patients bring...

The Psychoanalytic Theories of Melanie Klein

The Psychoanalytic Theories of Melanie Klein

Exploring the Earliest Stages of Psychic Life "The early ego lacks cohesion, and a tendency towards integration alternates with a tendency towards disintegration, a falling into bits... The result is an acute feeling of insecurity." 1. Who Was Melanie Klein Melanie...

Mircea Eliade’s Insights into the Sacred

Mircea Eliade’s Insights into the Sacred

In The Sacred and the Profane (1957), the Romanian historian of religions Mircea Eliade argued that religious people do not experience space and time as uniform. A hierophany, a breakthrough of the sacred, sets up a fixed center that orients everything around it, and...

Richard Tarnas: Cultural History Through Astrology

Richard Tarnas: Cultural History Through Astrology

The Historian of the Western Soul In 1991, Richard Tarnas published a book that became standard reading in universities worldwide: The Passion of the Western Mind. It was a brilliant, sweeping history of Western thought from Plato to Hegel to Jung. But in 2006, he...

3 Ways Your Shadow Shows Up as Animals in Myths and Dreams

3 Ways Your Shadow Shows Up as Animals in Myths and Dreams

Carl Jung thought that dreams were the way that we use the past to try and conceptualize what the future will be like. When we are on the edge of a big often unavoidable change in our life we begin to dig into our unconscious mind to try to predict the future. Our...

What the Ancient Mysteries Knew About Healing Trauma

What the Ancient Mysteries Knew About Healing Trauma

The Eleusinian, Mithraic, and Dionysian mysteries weren’t religious observances. They were orchestrated psychodramas designed to shatter the ego and rebuild the self. Modern trauma therapy has inadvertently reconstructed their methods.

Naomi Quenk’s Work on the Inferior Function

Naomi Quenk’s Work on the Inferior Function

You've had the experience. You're usually calm, but suddenly you're screaming at your partner over dishes. You're normally logical, but you're sobbing uncontrollably about something that "shouldn't" matter. You're typically easygoing, but you've become rigidly fixated...

Understanding How the Different Types of Therapy Fit Together

Understanding How the Different Types of Therapy Fit Together

Most types of therapy fall into five families: cognitive-behavioral therapies (CBT, exposure, behavioral activation), skills and acceptance therapies (DBT, ACT), trauma-processing therapies (cognitive processing therapy, prolonged exposure, EMDR), body-based and...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *