Is BPD really multiple disorders?

by | Aug 2, 2023 | 0 comments

Borderline personality disorder is one diagnosis in the DSM, but it behaves like several. A person needs only five of nine criteria, so two people with the same label can share a single symptom. Theodore Millon took that seriously: he described four borderline subtypes, each a blend of borderline instability with another personality style, which helps explain why borderline suffering looks so different from one person to the next.

Key takeaways

  • Because any five of nine DSM criteria qualify, borderline personality disorder can be diagnosed in 256 different combinations, so people with the same label can look very different.
  • Theodore Millon described four borderline subtypes, discouraged, impulsive, petulant and self-destructive, each blending borderline instability with another personality style.
  • Millon saw personality disorders as failed adaptations, a psychological immune system under strain, rather than diseases a person catches.
  • Adults with BPD are far more likely to report childhood adversity, especially emotional abuse and neglect, which supports reading borderline traits as adaptations to an unreliable environment.
  • BPD is treatable: long-term follow-up shows most people reach lasting symptom remission, and DBT, MBT and psychodynamic therapies all have trial support.

Is BPD really one disorder or several?

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is among the most stigmatized diagnoses in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). People carrying it are still described as manipulative or untreatable, and many clinicians quietly avoid them. A more useful way to see BPD is as a pattern of emotional, relational and identity instability that usually grows in a hard developmental environment: a nervous system that was never helped to settle, inside relationships that felt unsafe or unpredictable.

The DSM lists nine criteria: frantic efforts to avoid abandonment, unstable and intense relationships, an unstable sense of self, impulsivity, recurrent self-harm or suicidal behaviour, mood reactivity, chronic emptiness, intense anger, and stress-related paranoia or dissociation. Any five qualify. Counting the combinations of five or more out of nine gives 256 different ways to meet the diagnosis. One person may be quiet, ashamed and clinging, even a covert borderline whose pain hides behind confidence; another may be explosive, reckless and charming. Both receive the same code.

This is why the question “is BPD really multiple disorders?” keeps coming up. Theodore Millon gave one of the most clinically useful answers. He did not treat borderline as a random list of symptoms. He treated it as a structural personality pattern, a more severe and less integrated version of other basic styles, that developed as a way of surviving a chaotic world. Read that way, BPD is one level of breakdown that shows up in several distinct forms.2

Who was Theodore Millon?

Theodore Millon (1928 to 2014) was an American psychologist who spent his career building a theory of personality and its disorders, part of a longer history of personality psychology. He was born in New York City, taught for many years at the University of Miami, and founded the Institute for Advanced Studies in Personology and Psychopathology. He died on 29 January 2014 at his home in Greenville, New York.5

Millon was unusual because he insisted that diagnosis needed a theory underneath it. In Toward a New Personology (1990) he grounded personality in evolutionary principles, describing three polarities every organism has to manage: seeking pleasure versus avoiding pain, actively shaping the environment versus passively accommodating to it, and investing in the self versus investing in others.1 A personality style, in his view, is a characteristic way of balancing those tasks. Before a clinician can treat a pattern, he argued, they need to understand what the pattern is for.

He is best remembered for his role in the third edition of the DSM. As a member of the DSM-III task force he drafted much of the personality disorder section, and DSM-III (1980) introduced the multiaxial system, which placed personality disorders on their own Axis II beside the acute conditions on Axis I.5 That arrangement asked every clinician to consider the enduring person, not only the current episode of depression or anxiety. He also developed the Millon Clinical Multiaxial Inventory, first published in 1977, which became one of the most used self-report measures of personality pathology, and he contributed to the personality work behind DSM-IV (1994).

Millon and the DSM-5

Millon was not part of the DSM-5 work group. During the years when that group proposed replacing most personality disorder categories with a trait-based model, he published his own alternative in the third edition of Disorders of Personality (2011), which set out a spectrum running from normal personality styles to their disordered forms and mapped it onto both the DSM and the ICD.3 In his last review he placed himself among the theory-driven “deductivists,” alongside Otto Kernberg, in contrast with researchers who build classifications inductively from trait statistics.4 His concern was that a list of trait scores, without a theory of how traits fit together and what they do, loses the person who carries them. DSM-5 appeared in May 2013, eight months before his death.

Timeline of Theodore Millon’s contributions

Year Event / Publication
1928 Born in New York City.
1969 Publishes Modern Psychopathology, introducing his biosocial learning theory.
1980 Serves as a key member of the DSM-III Task Force, establishing the Multiaxial System.
1996 Publishes Disorders of Personality: DSM-IV and Beyond, detailing the BPD subtypes.
2013 DSM-5 is published; Millon criticizes its removal of the multiaxial system.
2014 Dies in Greenville, SC.

What are Millon’s four subtypes of borderline personality?

Millon recognized that two people with BPD can look completely different, and he described four subtypes in Disorders of Personality: DSM-IV and Beyond (1996, written with Roger Davis).2 Each subtype is borderline instability combined with features of another personality pattern. Knowing which blend you are seeing changes how a therapist paces the work, whether the frame is Internal Family Systems, DBT or psychodynamic therapy.

The discouraged borderline

This subtype combines borderline features with avoidant, dependent and depressive ones. These people are not acting out; they are acting in. They are often compliant, submissive and clinging, not from entitlement but from a deep sense of helplessness. They feel they have no right to exist independently and attach to a stronger figure to feel safe, then sink into despair when that figure seems to pull away.

Key feature: “I am nothing without you.” Clinically, many of these clients describe emotional neglect, homes where having needs drew no response or drew punishment, so the safest strategy was to need quietly and never leave.

The impulsive borderline

Here the instability is turned outward, and Millon linked this subtype to histrionic and antisocial features. These people are often charismatic, energetic and flirtatious, and prone to sudden loss of control. They seek stimulation through sex, substances, spending or risk to drown out emptiness or a sense of doom, and they can swing quickly from warmth to coldness when attention fades.

Key feature: “I need to feel something, anything, right now.” The urgency makes sense as a regulation strategy: intense stimulation quiets unbearable inner states for a while. It connects closely with the neurobiology of shame, where an unbearable feeling about the self drives a rush toward anything that will make it stop.

The petulant borderline

This subtype mixes borderline features with negativistic, or passive-aggressive, ones. It is marked by impatience, irritability, stubbornness and defiance. These people often feel wronged by the world and demand restitution. They test relationships by pushing people away, then feel confirmed when the person leaves: “I knew you didn’t love me.” The defence runs, “I will reject you before you can reject me.”

Key feature: “You owe me this because you hurt me.” The pattern resembles the “moving against people” strategy that Karen Horney described in Our Inner Conflicts (1945), one of her three neurotic personality styles: a fight response from a child who felt unprotected and learned that anger at least kept people at a controllable distance.

The self-destructive borderline

Millon tied this subtype to depressive and masochistic features. These people turn their rage inward. On the surface they may be conforming, deferential and high-functioning, while underneath they carry intense self-hatred and bitterness. They may punish themselves for having needs or feelings at all. Self-harm here is less a cry for help than a way of carrying out a sentence on the self for imagined crimes.

Key feature: “I am bad and I deserve to suffer.” This is the subtype at highest risk of self-harm and suicide. Psychodynamic clinicians often understand the self-attack as a safety valve: rage that would threaten a needed relationship with a parent or partner is redirected at the self, which protects the bond at the cost of the person.

Why did Millon see personality disorders as structures, not diseases?

Millon’s most important reframe was that personality disorders are not illnesses one catches, like a virus, but adaptations that failed. He compared personality to a psychological immune system: the enduring set of ways a person meets stress and protects themselves.2 In BPD that system is both overactive and poorly organized, attacking the self and others to ward off abandonment.

In his scheme, borderline sits with paranoid and schizotypal patterns as one of the more severe, “structurally defective” personalities. Each develops from less severe basic styles when those styles are pushed past what they can hold. Millon had even preferred the name “cycloid” for this pattern, to describe its swings rather than imply that the person lives on a border with psychosis.2 This is the deepest sense in which BPD is “multiple”: the borderline level of organization is shared, while the underlying style, whether dependent, histrionic, negativistic or masochistic, is different in each subtype.

Kernberg reached a related conclusion from object relations theory. In Borderline Conditions and Pathological Narcissism (1975) he described “borderline personality organization” as a level of functioning marked by identity diffusion, primitive defences such as splitting, and generally intact reality testing, a level that can underlie several different character styles.8 Millon and Kernberg started from different theories and both arrived at a borderline that is better described as a structure than as a single disease.

What happened to Cluster B and the multiaxial system?

DSM-III grouped the personality disorders into three clusters. Cluster B, the dramatic, emotional and erratic group, contains borderline, narcissistic, histrionic and antisocial personality disorders. Millon saw these patterns as related ways of meeting the same polarities, and in practice they overlap heavily: many people diagnosed with BPD also meet criteria for another Cluster B condition, often shaped by the same chaotic early environment.

The clusters were not removed in DSM-5. What changed in 2013 was the end of the multiaxial system: Axis II disappeared, and personality disorders were listed with every other diagnosis. The DSM-5 work group had also proposed cutting five of the ten personality disorders and moving to a trait model. That proposal drew sharp objections, including a 2010 letter from Jonathan Shedler, Peter Fonagy, Glen Gabbard, John Gunderson, Otto Kernberg and others, who argued that clinicians think in terms of whole personality syndromes and that the proposed system would be hard to use.6 The final DSM-5 kept the ten categories in its main section and placed the trait-based Alternative Model in Section III for further study.

The ICD-11, in use since January 2022, went further. It replaced the separate personality disorder categories with a single diagnosis rated by severity, mild, moderate or severe, with optional trait domains: negative affectivity, detachment, dissociality, disinhibition and anankastia. After a long debate the World Health Organization working group added a “borderline pattern” specifier, because many clinicians argued that the borderline picture was too clinically useful to lose.7 Both manuals now sit on the question Millon raised: is borderline one thing, or a level of severity that takes several forms? For more on that debate, see whether the DSM is dying.

The risk in a flatter, purely descriptive model is that it loses the patient’s story. Millon’s subtypes help clients understand why they act the way they do, and that understanding is often the first step in healing from relational injury, including narcissistic abuse in the family of origin.

How is borderline personality connected to trauma?

The link between early adversity and BPD is one of the most consistent findings in the field. A 2020 meta-analysis of 97 studies found that adults with BPD were about 13.9 times more likely than non-clinical controls to report childhood adversity, and about 3 times more likely than people with other psychiatric diagnoses. Emotional abuse and neglect showed the largest effects.9 Adversity is not destiny, and not everyone with BPD has a trauma history, but the pattern supports reading borderline traits as adaptations to an environment that could not be relied on.

Marsha Linehan’s biosocial theory says something similar in different words: a child with a sensitive, reactive temperament grows up in an invalidating environment, where their emotions are ignored, punished or dismissed, and never learns to name, trust or regulate those emotions.11 Millon’s subtypes add the point that the adaptation takes different shapes: the discouraged child clings, the impulsive child seeks stimulation, the petulant child fights, the self-destructive child turns the fight inward.

BPD also overlaps with complex PTSD, which the ICD-11 lists as a separate diagnosis and which Judith Herman first described in 1992. A latent class analysis by Marylene Cloitre and colleagues found that the two can be told apart: four symptoms, frantic efforts to avoid abandonment, an unstable sense of self, unstable intense relationships and impulsivity, most strongly marked the BPD group rather than the complex PTSD group.10 Many clients carry features of both, which is part of why a careful formulation matters more than the label. Our guide to complex PTSD covers that side in more depth, and BPD is also often confused with bipolar disorder.

Is borderline personality disorder treatable?

Yes. The “untreatable” reputation is out of date. In Mary Zanarini’s McLean Study of Adult Development, which followed 290 inpatients with BPD for 16 years, 78% to 99% achieved symptomatic remission lasting at least two years. Full recovery, meaning remission plus good social and vocational functioning, was harder: 40% to 60% reached it.15 Symptoms usually ease; building a life takes longer and is where much of therapy’s work lies.

Several psychotherapies designed for BPD have strong trial support. Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) halved suicide attempts compared with treatment by community experts in Linehan’s 2006 trial with chronically suicidal women.12 Mentalization-based treatment (MBT), developed by Anthony Bateman and Peter Fonagy, helps people hold their own and other people’s minds in mind under stress; in an 18-month trial it produced steeper reductions in suicide attempts, self-harm and hospitalization than structured clinical management.13 Transference-focused psychotherapy, built on Kernberg’s model, works directly with the split images of self and other as they appear in the therapy relationship.

A meta-analysis of 33 randomized trials found that BPD-specific psychotherapies outperformed control treatments for borderline symptoms, self-harm and suicidality, and that DBT and psychodynamic approaches were the two families of therapy with effects strong enough to stand on their own.14 No single school owns the outcome. What these treatments share is a clear structure, a steady relationship and sustained attention to emotion and attachment.

How do therapists use Millon’s subtypes in practice?

At Taproot we use Millon’s subtypes as a map, not a verdict. They tell us what the borderline pattern is protecting and which relational dance is most likely to appear in the room. With a discouraged client, the early work is often about tolerating separateness without collapse, so we watch for compliance that hides need. With an impulsive client, we look for the feeling that the action is outrunning. With a petulant client, we expect testing and try to survive it without retaliating or withdrawing, which is the repair the client never had. With a self-destructive client, safety comes first, and the work turns slowly toward the anger that has been aimed at the self.

Parts work fits this naturally. In IFS terms the clinging, the rush toward stimulation, the angry pushing away and the self-punishment are protectors guarding younger, wounded parts, and the history of IFS shows how the model was built to work with exactly those polarized systems. Edward Teyber’s focus on the interpersonal process in therapy adds the point that the old pattern will be re-enacted with the therapist, and that a different response there is itself healing.

Because so much borderline distress is held in the body as alarm, shame and shutdown, we also use brain-based and somatic approaches drawn from the neuroscience of trauma. Brainspotting helps clients process the raw activation underneath abandonment fears while staying anchored in a steady relationship, so that the old alarm can settle instead of driving the next crisis.

What is Millon’s legacy for understanding borderline?

Millon taught that a diagnosis is not a stamp of doom but a map of the territory. His work connects the biology of temperament with the biography of the person, and his subtypes let a therapist move past generic coping skills toward the specific structural wound each client carries. Whether the treatment is DBT, MBT, psychodynamic therapy or parts work, his taxonomy remains a practical tool for helping people through the storms of the borderline experience. If that kind of slow, relational and body-aware work fits what you are looking for, you can contact Taproot Therapy Collective to talk with one of our therapists.

Frequently asked questions

What are the four types of borderline personality disorder?

Theodore Millon described four borderline subtypes. The discouraged borderline blends borderline traits with avoidant, dependent and depressive features. The impulsive borderline adds histrionic or antisocial features. The petulant borderline adds negativistic, passive-aggressive features. The self-destructive borderline adds depressive and masochistic features and turns anger inward. These are clinical descriptions from his theory, not separate official diagnoses.

Why do people with BPD seem so different from each other?

A diagnosis of borderline personality disorder requires any five of nine DSM criteria, which allows 256 combinations. Two people can share only one symptom. Millon added that borderline instability combines with a different underlying personality style in each person, so one may be quiet and clinging while another is explosive and reckless.

Did the DSM-5 remove Cluster B personality disorders?

No. DSM-5 kept all ten personality disorders and the three clusters, including Cluster B with borderline, narcissistic, histrionic and antisocial personality disorder. What it removed in 2013 was the multiaxial system, so personality disorders are no longer listed on a separate Axis II. A trait-based alternative model was placed in Section III.

How does ICD-11 diagnose borderline personality disorder?

ICD-11, in use since 2022, gives a single personality disorder diagnosis rated mild, moderate or severe, with optional trait domains such as negative affectivity and disinhibition. Clinicians can add a borderline pattern specifier, which was kept after debate because many argued the borderline picture is too clinically useful to lose.

Is borderline personality disorder caused by trauma?

Childhood adversity is strongly linked to BPD. A 2020 meta-analysis of 97 studies found adults with BPD were about 13.9 times more likely than non-clinical controls to report childhood adversity, with emotional abuse and neglect showing the largest effects. Temperament also matters, and not everyone with BPD has a trauma history, but the link is consistent.

Can borderline personality disorder get better?

Yes. In a 16-year follow-up of 290 former inpatients, 78% to 99% of people with borderline personality disorder reached symptom remission lasting at least two years, though full recovery of work and social life was harder. Therapies built for BPD, including DBT, mentalization-based treatment and psychodynamic therapy, reduce self-harm and borderline symptoms.

References

  1. Millon, T. (1990). Toward a new personology: An evolutionary model. Wiley.
  2. Millon, T., & Davis, R. D. (1996). Disorders of personality: DSM-IV and beyond (2nd ed.). Wiley.
  3. Millon, T. (2011). Disorders of personality: Introducing a DSM/ICD spectrum from normal to abnormal (3rd ed.). Wiley.
  4. Millon, T. (2012). On the history and future study of personality and its disorders. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 8, 1–19. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-032511-143113
  5. Tringone, R., Jolosky, T., & Strack, S. (2014). Theodore Millon (1928–2014). American Psychologist, 69(5), 552. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0036948
  6. Shedler, J., Beck, A., Fonagy, P., Gabbard, G. O., Gunderson, J., Kernberg, O., Michels, R., & Westen, D. (2010). Personality disorders in DSM-5. American Journal of Psychiatry, 167(9), 1026–1028. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2010.10050746
  7. Tyrer, P., Mulder, R., Kim, Y.-R., & Crawford, M. J. (2019). The development of the ICD-11 classification of personality disorders: An amalgam of science, pragmatism, and politics. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 15, 481–502. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-050718-095736
  8. Kernberg, O. F. (1975). Borderline conditions and pathological narcissism. Jason Aronson.
  9. Porter, C., Palmier-Claus, J., Branitsky, A., Mansell, W., Warwick, H., & Varese, F. (2020). Childhood adversity and borderline personality disorder: A meta-analysis. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 141(1), 6–20. https://doi.org/10.1111/acps.13118
  10. Cloitre, M., Garvert, D. W., Weiss, B., Carlson, E. B., & Bryant, R. A. (2014). Distinguishing PTSD, complex PTSD, and borderline personality disorder: A latent class analysis. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 5, 25097. https://doi.org/10.3402/ejpt.v5.25097
  11. Linehan, M. M. (1993). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder. Guilford Press.
  12. Linehan, M. M., Comtois, K. A., Murray, A. M., Brown, M. Z., Gallop, R. J., Heard, H. L., Korslund, K. E., Tutek, D. A., Reynolds, S. K., & Lindenboim, N. (2006). Two-year randomized controlled trial and follow-up of dialectical behavior therapy vs therapy by experts for suicidal behaviors and borderline personality disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry, 63(7), 757–766. https://doi.org/10.1001/archpsyc.63.7.757
  13. Bateman, A., & Fonagy, P. (2009). Randomized controlled trial of outpatient mentalization-based treatment versus structured clinical management for borderline personality disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry, 166(12), 1355–1364. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2009.09040539
  14. Cristea, I. A., Gentili, C., Cotet, C. D., Palomba, D., Barbui, C., & Cuijpers, P. (2017). Efficacy of psychotherapies for borderline personality disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry, 74(4), 319–328. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2016.4287
  15. Zanarini, M. C., Frankenburg, F. R., Reich, D. B., & Fitzmaurice, G. (2012). Attainment and stability of sustained symptomatic remission and recovery among patients with borderline personality disorder and Axis II comparison subjects: A 16-year prospective follow-up study. American Journal of Psychiatry, 169(5), 476–483. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2011.11101550

Explore the Other Articles by Categories on Our Blog 

Why are Trauma Patients Afraid of Space

Why are Trauma Patients Afraid of Space

Our phobias are often metaphors for our most unconscious parts of self. In the 2013 movie Gravity, Sandra Bullock plays an astronaut marooned in space. At every moment she is seconds from spinning into the hopeless oblivion of deep space. Bullock’s character must use...

The Neuroscience and Phenomenology of Brainspotting

The Neuroscience and Phenomenology of Brainspotting

The neuroscience of brainspotting is a model of how holding the eyes on one spot in the visual field engages the midbrain orienting system, the amygdala and memory circuits so that stored trauma can be processed. Its phenomenology is what clients feel while that...

Why We Recommend Hardy Nutritionals: A Clinical Perspective on the Research That Changed How We Think About Treatment Resistance

Why We Recommend Hardy Nutritionals: A Clinical Perspective on the Research That Changed How We Think About Treatment Resistance

Why Taproot Therapy Collective recommends Hardy Nutritionals Daily Essential Nutrients for treatment-resistant mood disorders, ADHD, and emotional dysregulation. Discovered not through advertising but through patients whose bipolar disorder and other conditions finally responded. Over 40 peer-reviewed studies support the NutraTek chelation technology. Use code TAPROOT at gethardy.com for 15% off for life.

Who Is Victor Lamme?

Who Is Victor Lamme?

The Neuroscientist Who Found Consciousness in the Feedback Loops of the Brain When you look at a face, what happens in your brain? The answer turns out to be surprisingly complex. First, visual information streams forward from your eyes through your visual cortex,...

Somatic Reset Techniques You Can do At Home

Somatic Reset Techniques You Can do At Home

Updated November 2026 · By Joel Blackstock, LICSW-S The somatic exercises most often suggested for trauma at home are Tension and Trauma Releasing Exercises (TRE), self-havening touch, and body-focused parts work drawn from Somatic Internal Family Systems. Done gently...

Who is Mark Turner?

Who is Mark Turner?

The Literary Mind: Mark Turner's Cognitive Science and Its Implications for Understanding Trauma and Consciousness in Psychotherapy In the quest to understand the complexities of human consciousness and the impact of trauma on the psyche, the work of cognitive...

Who is Cliford Geertz?

Who is Cliford Geertz?

Weaving the Web of Meaning: Clifford Geertz's Cultural Anthropology and Its Implications for Trauma and Consciousness in Psychotherapy In the realm of psychotherapy, understanding the intricate tapestry of human experience is paramount. To truly grasp the complexities...

The Psychology of the Dragon Archetype

The Psychology of the Dragon Archetype

The dragon archetype is the recurring image of a vast, dangerous creature that guards a treasure, a threshold or a source of life. In Jungian psychology it stands for the overwhelming energies of the unconscious: the Shadow, the pull back toward the mother, raw...

The Mystical Roots and Therapeutic Fruits of Initiation Rites

The Mystical Roots and Therapeutic Fruits of Initiation Rites

Initiation rites are ceremonies that move a person from one state of life to another through a staged experience of separation, ordeal and return, often pictured as a symbolic death and rebirth. Their roots lie in tribal rites of passage and in the ancient mystery...

Unraveling the Mystery of the Roman Dodecahedra:

Unraveling the Mystery of the Roman Dodecahedra:

Roman dodecahedra are small hollow bronze objects with twelve pentagonal faces, a round hole in each face and a knob at each corner, made mostly in Gaul between the 2nd and 4th centuries CE. About 130 are known and no ancient text explains them. One reading links them...

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *